Federal Fiscal Court ruling: Excessive purchase price - real estate transfer tax alongside gift tax and hidden profit distribution
Where a limited liability company [GmbH] pays a person close to its shareholder an excessive purchase price for a property, real estate transfer tax is assessed on the full purchase price (section 8(1) of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act [Grunderwerbsteuergesetz–GrEStG]) – even if the excess price, as a hidden profit distribution [verdeckte Gewinnausschüttung–vGA], simultaneously triggers gift tax. An amendment of the real estate transfer tax assessment on account of conflicting tax assessments under section 174(1) sentence 1 of the Fiscal Code [Abgabenordnung–AO] is ruled out, because the relationship of mutual exclusivity between the two taxes covers only gifts of real property within the meaning of section 3 no. 2 sentence 1 of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act. The decision confirms that section 174 of the Fiscal Code is not a general instrument for overriding the finality of assessments (Federal Fiscal Court [Bundesfinanzhof–BFH] judgement of 29 Jul 2026, file ref. II R 11/24).